Font size:
Print
What Is the Magna Carta and Why Does It Matter?
Context: Over eight centuries ago, the Magna Carta, or “Great Charter,” was sealed at Runnymede Meadows near London, marking a crucial turning point in the evolution of democratic principles.
More on News
- Signed on June 15, 1215, the charter was a response to mounting pressure from English barons determined to limit King John’s arbitrary use of power.
- In May 2025, Harvard University revealed a major discovery — one of the earliest known versions of the Magna Carta, previously thought to be a mere copy, actually dates back to 1300.
Origins: Born Out of Taxation and Rebellion
- The Magna Carta emerged in a period of military failure and financial strain.
- After losing key territories like Normandy and Anjou in 1204, King John increased taxes to fund repeated — and unsuccessful — military campaigns.
- His crushing defeat at the Battle of Bouvines in 1214 alienated powerful barons who had grown weary of his leadership.
- As part of the feudal system, these barons controlled land and were expected to supply troops in times of war.
- With John continuing to push for further conflict, their opposition escalated.
- They rebelled, ultimately compelling him to sign a document that would become one of the most significant political agreements in Western history.
A Groundbreaking But Limited Charter
- According to historian J.C. Holt, such agreements weren’t unique in medieval Europe.
- Still, the Magna Carta was notable for asserting legal constraints on the monarch at a time when power was absolute and hereditary privilege the norm.
- Holt called it a “primitive” but vital step on a long and complex path toward constitutional governance.
- The original Magna Carta contained 63 clauses and over 3,500 words, some focused on local administrative issues. However, certain clauses had lasting legal resonance:
- Clause 39: “No free man shall be arrested or imprisoned… except by the lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land.”
- Clause 40: “To no one will we sell, to no one will we deny or delay right or justice.”
- These clauses laid the groundwork for fundamental concepts like due process and equal access to justice, and copies were distributed across counties to ensure public awareness.
Political Backlash and Reaffirmation
- Despite sealing the Magna Carta, King John quickly sought to annul it with help from Pope Innocent III, sparking renewed conflict.
- The barons, in turn, invited the French prince to claim the English throne. King John died in 1216, and his nine-year-old son Henry III was crowned soon after.
- To restore stability, Henry’s supporters reissued the charter, gradually embedding it into English legal tradition.
- Over time, various updated versions followed. Today, four original copies of the 1215 Magna Carta survive, with a 1297 version fetching $21.3 million at auction in 2007.
Criticisms and Modern Legacy
- Critics argue that the Magna Carta primarily served the elite, addressing the rights of barons and “free men”, a term excluding women and serfs who made up the majority of the population.
- A BBC report from 2015 pointed out that it was not a document of democratic inclusivity but a power-sharing agreement among the privileged.
- Still, its symbolic value has grown over the centuries. Historian David Carpenter noted that it imposed “radical and detailed restrictions on the ruler”, establishing the rule of law — a concept central to modern democracies.
- Clauses 39 and 40 remain part of the UK legal system, underpinning principles such as habeas corpus, which guards against unlawful detention.
Global Influence and Enduring Symbolism
- The Magna Carta inspired legal systems far beyond England. During the American Revolution, colonists invoked its principles to justify demands for liberty.
- Its influence is deeply embedded in the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights.
- According to the U.S. National Archives, the colonists believed Magna Carta affirmed their inherent rights as Englishmen, and its ideals were essential in crafting a new democratic order.
- Though not originally intended to democratise governance, the Magna Carta today stands as a powerful symbol of constitutionalism, civil liberties, and the limits of state power.
